Version 2.1

Abolition Ethics

Explore the moral framework behind abolitionist resistance.

18 min readΒ·Qualified Lesson

Abolition Ethics

Movement Strategy & Ethics
Pod Leadership & Organizing

Info

Abolition isn’t just about tearing down harmful systems. It’s about building life-affirming alternatives grounded in care, accountability, and liberation.


Info

Key Terms:

  • Carceral logic: The belief that punishment is the proper response to harm.
  • Transformative justice: Addressing harm without relying on punishment, incarceration, or policing.
  • Mutual aid: Voluntary cooperation for shared benefit, often in defiance of state neglect.
  • Disposability: The idea that some people are worth less and can be cast aside.
  • Praxis: The combination of theory and action β€” ideas we put into daily practice.

What Is Abolition?

Abolition means more than the absence of police or prisons. It is:

  • A commitment to ending systems of punishment, control, and caging
  • A practice of rebuilding communities with safety, care, and mutual accountability
  • A refusal to accept violence as justice

Abolition is a moral stance rooted in the belief that no one is disposable.


Historical Roots

Abolitionism originally referred to the movement to end slavery. Modern abolition builds on this legacy by opposing all systems of racialized captivityβ€”including mass incarceration, immigration enforcement, and institutionalization.

Influences include:

  • The Black Radical Tradition
  • Indigenous sovereignty movements
  • Feminist and queer liberatory praxis
  • Restorative and transformative justice efforts

Hint

🧠 Explore the Combahee River Collective’s writings on interlocking systems of oppression.


Why Abolish ICE, Police, and Prisons?

These institutions:

  • Were founded in racial violence (e.g., slave patrols, settler militias)
  • Are inherently coercive, designed to maintain inequality
  • Fail to meet core needs like safety, shelter, or care
  • Disproportionately target Black, Brown, Indigenous, migrant, trans, disabled, and poor communities

Rabbit Hole

πŸ“š β€œPrisons do not disappear social problems, they disappear human beings.” β€” Angela Y. Davis
Read Are Prisons Obsolete? for more context.


The Ethical Logic of Abolition

Abolition ethics challenge us to ask:

  • What are the root causes of harm?
  • Can we respond without reproducing trauma or violence?
  • What would it take to create a world where policing isn’t necessary?

Abolition requires us to imagine and practice new responses to harmβ€”ones that heal, not harm further.


Accountability Without Violence

Abolition is not about ignoring harm. It’s about replacing punishment with transformation.

Abolitionist Responses to Harm

Harm ScenarioCarceral ResponseAbolitionist Alternative
TheftCall police, press chargesRestorative circle to address needs and repair relationships
Intimate partner violenceArrest perpetratorSafety planning, survivor-led community intervention
VandalismFines or jailRepair labor + dialogue about grievances

Hint

Practice: Role-play these scenarios with your pod using the Creative Interventions Toolkit.


Reform vs. Abolition

Why not just reform?

Warning

⚠️ Reforms like body cameras or predictive policing tech often expand police budgets and legitimacy.

  • Reforms usually strengthen institutions (e.g., funding for surveillance)
  • They rarely challenge the logic of punishment
  • Abolitionists argue these systems are functioning as designed β€” to control and exclude

Abolition pushes us to build new systems, not just patch old ones.


Abolition as Creation

Abolition is generative, not just subtractive.

  • Instead of prisons: Healing circles, housing, mental health care
  • Instead of police: Crisis teams, community patrols, de-escalators
  • Instead of deportation: Sanctuary networks, documentation aid, universal belonging

β€œAbolition is about presence, not absence. It's about building life-affirming institutions.”
β€” Ruth Wilson Gilmore


Practice-Based Ethics

Abolition is a daily practice, not just theory.

  • Interrupt carceral language (replace β€œguilty” or β€œdeserving” with neutral terms)
  • Make room for repair, growth, and return instead of exclusion
  • Use nonviolent communication in conflicts
  • Build resilience through mutual care, not state power

Pod Challenge:
Each week, identify one carceral habit (e.g., calling out rather than calling in) and replace it with an abolitionist alternative.


Disability, Class, and Global Justice

  • Disability Justice: Institutions often cage disabled people. Abolition includes dismantling these systems.
  • Class Dynamics: Carceral systems target poor communities across races.
  • Global Perspective: Abolition extends to borders, detention centers, and international solidarity (e.g., groups like No More Deaths).

Abolition in the ICE Tea Ecosystem

ICE Tea Academy applies abolitionist ethics by:

  • Protecting communities from surveillance and detention
  • Educating on liberatory practices
  • Refusing to collaborate with punitive systems
  • Designing tools and dispatch roles rooted in care, not control

Summary: Abolition Ethics at a Glance

EthicPractice Example
No one is disposableIntervene in harm with compassion
Care is the foundationBuild safe spaces, not punitive ones
Liberation is collectiveWork across lines of difference
Harm requires transformationCenter healing and change, not punishment
Build new systemsCreate mutual aid, housing, and crisis networks

Reflection & Action

Who do you become when you believe no one is disposable?
What would change in your organizing? Your relationships?

This Week’s Action:
Commit to one abolitionist practice (e.g., supporting a bail fund, auditing your org’s policies for carceral language, joining a TJ collective).

Success

Take the Abolitionist Pledge:
β€œI commit to three acts of abolitionist care this month β€” for myself, my pod, and my community.”


Resource Hub

  • Books: We Do This ’Til We Free Us (Mariame Kaba)
  • Lesson Plans: Project NIA
  • Orgs: Critical Resistance, Survived & Punished, No More Deaths

Ready to Qualify?

If you can explain the difference between punishment and accountability, understand the roots of abolition, and commit to practicing these ethics, mark this lesson as complete.

πŸ“˜ Knowledge Check

What is the primary ethical stance of abolition?

Abolition ethics believe violence can be a necessary form of justice.

Which of the following are examples of life-affirming alternatives to policing and prisons?

Why do abolitionists reject reform as a long-term solution?

Why do abolitionists often oppose institutions like ICE, police, and prisons?

Accountability in abolitionist practice means punishing someone for the harm they caused.

What does the quote β€œAbolition is about presence, not absence” mean?

In abolitionist practice, what does β€œbuilding in the negative” mean?

Which practices reflect abolitionist values?

The ICE Tea ecosystem integrates abolitionist values into its design and operations.

Which of the following is NOT a historical influence on modern abolition?

What distinguishes transformative justice from punitive justice?


🚫 You must register and log in to mark this lesson as qualified. Registering helps us track progress, verify training, and build trust across our network.

You can use your Dispatch login here if you already created an account there. Likewise, creating an account here will let you use the same credentials on Dispatch.

Complete and pass the quiz above to unlock this button. You’ll need at least 80% correct.